It's funny to me to watch people who, earlier on, had a balanced view of what was happening with Sam vs Drew go spiraling down the Mike Salk hot-takes rabbit hole.
A little basic (okay, maybe a little too basic) math: is it reasonable to assume that if your quarterback is 90% as good as some other quarterback that you're likely to win 90% as many games? Well, that's the Seahawks 2024 season. If there's one person on this feed who would be happy putting the 2024 season on repeat, I would be flabbergasted.
Yeah, that's a bit simplistic, but it's also simplistic to negate stronger competition, weaker o-line play, no running game, and no time to throw when everyone in the house knows you have to in favor of a flawed narrative. You want to compare apples to apples, you could do just as well comparing the Cardinals game last year with Sam at QB where the Seahawks were up 35-nothing in the third quarter against Drew's much - closer scores against basically the same team.
None of these comparisons are demonstrably accurate, and all of them overlook too many variables. But I've said before and I believe now that if you give Sam what you know he needs to thrive, he will.
Daniel Jeremiah said something I agree with: Sam has a higher ceiling and lower floor than Drew. Drew might get you to the playoffs, but does he have a game in him like the ‘25 NFC Championship Game?
I love Drew Lock, but I hope we never find out the answer to that question.
Let's give Sam a shot and wish him the very best. Go Hawks!
In regards to this post: I am entirely in favor of only using plays where JSN is the first read. Really, I see the coaches have lots of color coding on their charts and we should have one page that has nothing but JSN first read plays. No one is arguing that any other wide receiver on the team deserves or has earned any better treatment than that. And JSN has certainly earned it.
However, when you say, before we waste the best player in the league's best years or something like that, but isn't that almost always the case? Aaron Rodgers was arguably the best player in the league for at least 10 of his years playing, and all but one of those was "wasted" in the sense that he did not win the Super Bowl that year. We WILL waste most of JSN's career if that is how you see seasons, you have either wasted it or won the Super Bowl. I thoroughly understand that POV. I don't agree with it, but I understand it.
I enjoy the seasons that we don't get to the Super Bowl to some degree or another. And I hope we don't "waste" JSN's best years, either, no matter how you define that. JSN is enjoying himself I am sure, and most of us fans are enjoying watching him play, no doubt. What I pray for, other than another SB, is that JSN doesn't get hurt. Ever. End of story.
Thanks for reminding us that we are truely seeing something special in JSN, SJ. A great reminder we are being blessed with being able to witness it in real time.
For any Seahawks fans born after 1980 or 1990 who feel like "I didn't get to see Largent" and "I didn't get to see Cortez", it's a great time to soak it in and say "I get to see JSN".
My one caveat, is that Largent was absolutely at his best, and spent most of his time, catching passes against zone coverage. That was his super power. I don't think he was necessarily all that great against man on man except that no one ever seemed to design their game plan around using man on man against Largent, but I don't remember ever lacking a second WR worthy of being thrown to, either, the way our own team is.
I was alive and watching football when Largent was the best player on our team, but other than liking Largent, and enjoying all those catches he made, I was never a Largent "fan" in any sense of the word. So I am almost giddy with the idea that JSN will surpass Largent as the "greatest WR in Seahawks history." And Largent was admirable in every sense of the word. I fully admit it. I have no beef with Largent at all. However, JSN is poetry in motion, and has as good of hands as any WR ever. So I welcome him to his rightful place as the greatest WR in Seahawks history with open arms.
Oh, and I might mention that it’s a similar feeling with our Aussie legend, Dickson. I’m not sure there’s been as many kickers as consistently good over the length of time he has been.
I can understand letting Donald start. But I keep hearing on the podcast from KJR 710 etc. That he is the Super Bowl winning quarterback. But if they sign him to a new contract, we’re looking at probably about 50 million a year. I believe what they want to do is see If it is the injuries, the lack of a running game or he has just regressed.
I would have him on a very short leash and I would have no problem setting him
Because contracts are what you’re going to do in the future not what you did in the past If I believe lock do 90% of what Sam did for 25,000,000 to 30,000,000 a year I would be all over it and I would trade Sam to another team
We have Murphy coming up. We have to decide if we are going to keep love and we just traded for a all pro left guard if they wanna keep him it’s not going to be cheap.
That is my gut feeling what John is thinking about
I curb these conversations of what the Seahawks should do in 2027 until we see what happens for the remaining 50% of 2026 and the playoffs.
But these are the contractual facts:
-If the Seahawks trade Sam Darnold, they incur $19.2 million in dead cap for 2027. Plus he has 2 void years, leaving $12.8m dead cap in 2028 and $6.4m in 2029.
-If the Seahawks don't trade Darnold and do nothing, he has a $44.9m cap hit in 2027.
-If the Seahawks don't trade Darnold and they extend him to a 3-year, $150m contract (at this time that's only the 14th-biggest AAV for a QB), his cap hit could be $27 million, saving $18 million against the cap
-If the Seahawks trade Darnold and re-sign Drew Lock to the hypothetical 3-year, $90 million contract (if he would even agree to this), his first-year cap hit would be roughly $15 million. His second-year cap hit would be roughly $35 million. His third-year cap hit would be roughly $40 million.
So...
If the Seahawks trade Sam Darnold and re-sign Lock, they'd have total cap hits of $19m+15m = $44 million for the quarterback position. If they simply keep Darnold and don't touch his contract and roll with Milroe as backup, they'd have total cap hits of $45 million.
Then in 2028, the Seahawks would owe about $13 million for Darnold and about $35 million for Lock. Totaling about $50 million for the QB position. Whereas if they extend Darnold, they will save about $18 million in 2027 and probably be spending the same or less in 2028.
Furthermore, the Seahawks will be banking on Drew Lock -- at this point based on his starts against the Cardinals and Raiders -- a QB with 31 career starts, including 13 starts over the last 6 years. And they'll be locked into paying that QB $35m+ in 2028 based on this hypothetical. In comparison, Darnold has made 101 career starts, including 45 starts since 2024, and a Super Bowl in 2025.
If Lock stumbles in 2027, the Seahawks will still owe him in 2028. The situation is reminiscent of the Dolphins owing Malik Willis $26 million next year no matter what they do. We've seen countless "bet on the backup" contracts in history, from Osweiler to Keenum to Foles, and rare is the success story. Even Geno Smith's contract with the Seahawks in 2022 came after he spent 4 years as the backup and it was a one-year contrct for $7 million.
If Darnold stumbles in 2027, and the Seahawks don't extend his contract, they simply move on in 2028 with no further penalties.
If the hypothetical was "re-sign Drew Lock for a one-year, $10 million deal", maybe the value would offset. Under the proposed "90% rule" here, the cost to trade Darnold and re-sign Lock shows no 2027 savings and will cost the Seahawks even more in 2028, while losing cap space overall in the next 2-3 years compared to a very affordable $50 million extension for Darnold, as that figure is now bottom of the veteran starting tier.
I wrote my long reply while you posted this, so I'm repeating what you can see now, but if the Seahawks want to save cap space to pay other players, then their best bet by far is to extend Darnold. Lock would not be $20 million cheaper unless he signs a one-year, $5-$10 million contract.
Question: Salary cap aside, wouldn't trading Darnold likely bring us significant draft assets though? So a small cap savings to roll with Lock plus draft picks vs sticking with Sam for 3+ years. This assumes the next few Darnold starts continue to show signs of his regression. Raiders are the Raiders but they still have Maxx Crosby and Drew's pocket presence without both starting tackles looked solid.
Not so fast, there, fellas.
It's funny to me to watch people who, earlier on, had a balanced view of what was happening with Sam vs Drew go spiraling down the Mike Salk hot-takes rabbit hole.
A little basic (okay, maybe a little too basic) math: is it reasonable to assume that if your quarterback is 90% as good as some other quarterback that you're likely to win 90% as many games? Well, that's the Seahawks 2024 season. If there's one person on this feed who would be happy putting the 2024 season on repeat, I would be flabbergasted.
Yeah, that's a bit simplistic, but it's also simplistic to negate stronger competition, weaker o-line play, no running game, and no time to throw when everyone in the house knows you have to in favor of a flawed narrative. You want to compare apples to apples, you could do just as well comparing the Cardinals game last year with Sam at QB where the Seahawks were up 35-nothing in the third quarter against Drew's much - closer scores against basically the same team.
None of these comparisons are demonstrably accurate, and all of them overlook too many variables. But I've said before and I believe now that if you give Sam what you know he needs to thrive, he will.
Daniel Jeremiah said something I agree with: Sam has a higher ceiling and lower floor than Drew. Drew might get you to the playoffs, but does he have a game in him like the ‘25 NFC Championship Game?
I love Drew Lock, but I hope we never find out the answer to that question.
Let's give Sam a shot and wish him the very best. Go Hawks!
In regards to this post: I am entirely in favor of only using plays where JSN is the first read. Really, I see the coaches have lots of color coding on their charts and we should have one page that has nothing but JSN first read plays. No one is arguing that any other wide receiver on the team deserves or has earned any better treatment than that. And JSN has certainly earned it.
However, when you say, before we waste the best player in the league's best years or something like that, but isn't that almost always the case? Aaron Rodgers was arguably the best player in the league for at least 10 of his years playing, and all but one of those was "wasted" in the sense that he did not win the Super Bowl that year. We WILL waste most of JSN's career if that is how you see seasons, you have either wasted it or won the Super Bowl. I thoroughly understand that POV. I don't agree with it, but I understand it.
I enjoy the seasons that we don't get to the Super Bowl to some degree or another. And I hope we don't "waste" JSN's best years, either, no matter how you define that. JSN is enjoying himself I am sure, and most of us fans are enjoying watching him play, no doubt. What I pray for, other than another SB, is that JSN doesn't get hurt. Ever. End of story.
You're right, I did not mean to say "waste".
Thanks for reminding us that we are truely seeing something special in JSN, SJ. A great reminder we are being blessed with being able to witness it in real time.
For any Seahawks fans born after 1980 or 1990 who feel like "I didn't get to see Largent" and "I didn't get to see Cortez", it's a great time to soak it in and say "I get to see JSN".
My one caveat, is that Largent was absolutely at his best, and spent most of his time, catching passes against zone coverage. That was his super power. I don't think he was necessarily all that great against man on man except that no one ever seemed to design their game plan around using man on man against Largent, but I don't remember ever lacking a second WR worthy of being thrown to, either, the way our own team is.
I was alive and watching football when Largent was the best player on our team, but other than liking Largent, and enjoying all those catches he made, I was never a Largent "fan" in any sense of the word. So I am almost giddy with the idea that JSN will surpass Largent as the "greatest WR in Seahawks history." And Largent was admirable in every sense of the word. I fully admit it. I have no beef with Largent at all. However, JSN is poetry in motion, and has as good of hands as any WR ever. So I welcome him to his rightful place as the greatest WR in Seahawks history with open arms.
Oh, and I might mention that it’s a similar feeling with our Aussie legend, Dickson. I’m not sure there’s been as many kickers as consistently good over the length of time he has been.
I might be biased though 🇦🇺🦘
I can understand letting Donald start. But I keep hearing on the podcast from KJR 710 etc. That he is the Super Bowl winning quarterback. But if they sign him to a new contract, we’re looking at probably about 50 million a year. I believe what they want to do is see If it is the injuries, the lack of a running game or he has just regressed.
I would have him on a very short leash and I would have no problem setting him
Because contracts are what you’re going to do in the future not what you did in the past If I believe lock do 90% of what Sam did for 25,000,000 to 30,000,000 a year I would be all over it and I would trade Sam to another team
We have Murphy coming up. We have to decide if we are going to keep love and we just traded for a all pro left guard if they wanna keep him it’s not going to be cheap.
That is my gut feeling what John is thinking about
I curb these conversations of what the Seahawks should do in 2027 until we see what happens for the remaining 50% of 2026 and the playoffs.
But these are the contractual facts:
-If the Seahawks trade Sam Darnold, they incur $19.2 million in dead cap for 2027. Plus he has 2 void years, leaving $12.8m dead cap in 2028 and $6.4m in 2029.
-If the Seahawks don't trade Darnold and do nothing, he has a $44.9m cap hit in 2027.
-If the Seahawks don't trade Darnold and they extend him to a 3-year, $150m contract (at this time that's only the 14th-biggest AAV for a QB), his cap hit could be $27 million, saving $18 million against the cap
-If the Seahawks trade Darnold and re-sign Drew Lock to the hypothetical 3-year, $90 million contract (if he would even agree to this), his first-year cap hit would be roughly $15 million. His second-year cap hit would be roughly $35 million. His third-year cap hit would be roughly $40 million.
So...
If the Seahawks trade Sam Darnold and re-sign Lock, they'd have total cap hits of $19m+15m = $44 million for the quarterback position. If they simply keep Darnold and don't touch his contract and roll with Milroe as backup, they'd have total cap hits of $45 million.
Then in 2028, the Seahawks would owe about $13 million for Darnold and about $35 million for Lock. Totaling about $50 million for the QB position. Whereas if they extend Darnold, they will save about $18 million in 2027 and probably be spending the same or less in 2028.
Furthermore, the Seahawks will be banking on Drew Lock -- at this point based on his starts against the Cardinals and Raiders -- a QB with 31 career starts, including 13 starts over the last 6 years. And they'll be locked into paying that QB $35m+ in 2028 based on this hypothetical. In comparison, Darnold has made 101 career starts, including 45 starts since 2024, and a Super Bowl in 2025.
If Lock stumbles in 2027, the Seahawks will still owe him in 2028. The situation is reminiscent of the Dolphins owing Malik Willis $26 million next year no matter what they do. We've seen countless "bet on the backup" contracts in history, from Osweiler to Keenum to Foles, and rare is the success story. Even Geno Smith's contract with the Seahawks in 2022 came after he spent 4 years as the backup and it was a one-year contrct for $7 million.
If Darnold stumbles in 2027, and the Seahawks don't extend his contract, they simply move on in 2028 with no further penalties.
If the hypothetical was "re-sign Drew Lock for a one-year, $10 million deal", maybe the value would offset. Under the proposed "90% rule" here, the cost to trade Darnold and re-sign Lock shows no 2027 savings and will cost the Seahawks even more in 2028, while losing cap space overall in the next 2-3 years compared to a very affordable $50 million extension for Darnold, as that figure is now bottom of the veteran starting tier.
Thanks good info. We will see in the off season I guess
My brain hurts.
LOL MINE AS WELL! Glad we have SJ here for this type of info.
That's why teams have staff dedicated to just figuring out how to pay everybody.
The Bengals literally cancelled a trade last week because they didn't understand the compensatory pick system.
I don’t know why no team has offered you a position. You’re all over it!
Absolutely. Need to extend Murphy, Q Nelson, etc. I'd definitely want to roll with Lock is he's 20 mill cheaper than Darnold with what he's shown.
I wrote my long reply while you posted this, so I'm repeating what you can see now, but if the Seahawks want to save cap space to pay other players, then their best bet by far is to extend Darnold. Lock would not be $20 million cheaper unless he signs a one-year, $5-$10 million contract.
Read your response, thanks for that!
Question: Salary cap aside, wouldn't trading Darnold likely bring us significant draft assets though? So a small cap savings to roll with Lock plus draft picks vs sticking with Sam for 3+ years. This assumes the next few Darnold starts continue to show signs of his regression. Raiders are the Raiders but they still have Maxx Crosby and Drew's pocket presence without both starting tackles looked solid.