This newsletter is about why the Seahawks might not seem as dominant as they did last season and what Seattle will need out of their roster moving forward to get back to winning games more consistently and comfortably. The article might come across as an indictment of the front office or the team’s recent draftees, but it is only meant to be an assessment of what we know has happened already — not what we expect to happen in the future.
At this time, there are more starters on the Seahawks from the 2023 draft class than there are from the last three classes combined:
2023: Devon Witherspoon, Jaxon Smith-Njigba, Derick Hall, Zach Charbonnet, Anthony Bradford
2024-2026: Byron Murphy, A.J. Barner, Grey Zabel, Nick Emmanwori
The rookie class has been hit with injuries to the first three picks — Jadarian Price, Bud Clark, and Julian Neal — but if we’re being fair Clark is the only one who feels like he may have been a substantial loss this year; Price is back from IR so he’s not a “loss” anymore, plus he has played significantly fewer snaps than Charbonnet in the past two weeks; Neal’s been an afterthought since missing most of training camp with a leg injury.
Seattle’s “eight-player” rookie class has always been a true four-player class between those three and Beau Stephens. As I wrote on August 29, “the entire burden of getting value from the rookies this year may rest of Price” and that still looks to be the case. I noted the probability of the 2026 NFL Draft class being one of the weakest ever several times this offseason, writing that a player like Fuller would be fortunate to make the practice squad.
All four of Seattle’s 6th-7th round picks are on the practice squad—which also means none of the other 31 teams want to roster them either. This only bolsters the argument that the NIL (college players getting paid) has sapped day three of the draft of whatever value it had prior to recent times.
“But they’re just rookies.”
Zabel and Emmanwori were “just rookies” last year while they were helping the Seahawks win the Super Bowl. A notable commonality between many championship teams: Contributions from rookies.
That includes Seattle’s top-two picks in 2025, the Eagles’ secondary duo of Quinyon Mitchell and Cooper DeJean in 2024, and the Chiefs winning with Rashee Rice as their leading receiver in 2023. The year before, Kansas City’s rookie class was especially helpful, including Trent McDuffie, George Karlaftis, Jaylen Watson, Isiah Pacheco, Bryan Cook, and Leo Chenal.
Hopefully nobody twists these words into “Seaside Joe wrote that the Seahawks’ 2026 class is an entire bust” because that’s not what I said at all. Are Seattle’s rookies contributing in 2026, aside from Price, who has played in 21% of the snaps? No. And that’s all I’m saying: Facts and how those facts impact the current team, not future Seahawks teams.
