40 Comments
Oct 22, 2022Liked by Seaside Joe

WOW! Yes, I want to shout that out. WOW! As soon as I was done reading I was in a hurry to find the like button. My brother's name was Tony, but that is the least of my reasons for feeling closer to you now than at any point up till now.

You masterfully developed your theme, and then hit us with an entire paragraph that explained that theme in clear, unambiguous terms. I quote it in it's entirety:

"In my opinion, the best content will only be filtered through “What is true?”"

What a revolutionary thought in these days.

Expand full comment
Oct 22, 2022·edited Oct 22, 2022Liked by Seaside Joe

I don't hate Ben Baldwin, I rarely even think about Ben Baldwin. I chose to comment about him because I was in one of those moods, the joke presented itself and I thought it was funny (although it probably wasn't). :-)

But I do luv me some Kenny. Your arguments are well thought out and crafted and that puts you miles ahead of the Baldwins and Barnwells of the world.

Expand full comment
Oct 22, 2022Liked by Seaside Joe

I love this article but I'm sure you'd be just as happy if I hated it. What you can't afford is "meh".

Whether Pete's results have been good or bad (they've been good which makes this easier) the thing I enjoy about Pete is his love for the game and his positive attitude. Belichick is a great coach, but for me, his sideline grinch act detracts from the experince. Pete seems to embrace your philosophy of non-hate. Several players who the Hawks have cut have expressed anger and taken jabs at Pete including Thomas' famous finger. Pete defends them. The narrative I find funniest is that football has passed Pete by because he insists on running the ball. The unbaised fact is that Pete has been very adaptable throughout his career. He changed his coaching style before going to USC. Very few coaches can say they changed the game but Pete's 2012 defense did just that. Yet, here we are with a new defense and a new-fangled McVey offense that runs the ball. Damn, that old man is stubborn.

Expand full comment

Hey, I was featured today!

I like Ben Baldwin software a lot. I like his snark short comments to funny charts, but the rest of his twitter feed is toxic.

I think that the Belichick / Brady 20 year combo set some bars too high, and everyone falls short. Pete Carroll had many failures — and the one which most impacted us was poor drafting and ego-management since the first SB. The LOB tuned out, Russ became hard to please, and Carroll should have avoided or at least mitigated that better. Yes, he deserves that blame.

Like anyone, he has shortcomings that we need to understand – and it’s fair to criticize. For instance, he seems to still be a “college coach” in the sense he does really well with young guys and a high turnover, but was unable to build a dynasty from a historically great squad.

On the other hand, he seems to be the best DB scout / coach of all time. He makes bad teams competitive. He’s one of the winningest coaches in history (and has a better record without Wilson than Belichick without Brady).

Apart from the high bar there are the fads. Why aren’t you doing that trendy thing? Which makes people call Pete old, washed, stubborn. No, he knows football and wasn’t convinced from the fads. And maybe his past success with Russell Wilson (if he doesn’t succeed in a different team — though I hope he succeeds) will vindicate him.

Expand full comment

Ok, this is a topic near and dear to my heart.

First, Ben Baldwin. In the Twitterverse you need a take that is a bit controversial so that people want to argue with you--I get it. But I find his comments offer more heat than light and I rarely read them anymore. The stats guys (of whom Ba;ldwin is the flag bearer) want to treat football like baseball, and football just isn't that. The stats guys all say the same thing: pass, go for it on 4th down because the model says so, WR>RB etc. etc. Underneath it is a presumption that there is "one best way" to win in the NFL and anything else is on a scale between unenlightened and just plain dumb (and a source for ridicule).

I don't like engaging in conversations about Pete Carroll with folks who have not read "Win Forever". It isn't a hard book to read, and it sets out in full Pete's philosophy around football. He wrote it before the end of his first year with the Seahawks, and he hasn't changed much in his approach. What I appreciate most about Pete is that he HAS a point of view, a philosophy about football, and he is very consistent about how it is applied. We saw what he and John did to build the first SB version of the Seahawks. People say Pete/John got 'lucky' in the drafts of 2011 and 2012 but they were looking for a type, and they found it. The job Pete/John did building the team from the dregs available when they were hired was remarkable.

In Win Forever Pete sets out as his model Marv Levy, coach of the Bills team that made the SB four straight years. For Pete the point is to be able to compete at the highest level--the championship game itself is a bit of a crapshoot. Getting to and staying at the pinnacle of the NFL is a great accomplishment.

In the salary cap era it is difficult to keep the foundation of a championship team together. The 2012=2015 run was pretty darn good! In fact the only real criticism of Pete that I have is that he should have made the deal to trade Russ a year earlier than he did. But there is no question the team today is far superior to the 2021 version, and its future is brighter.

What Pete refers to as a "balanced offense" is far more run-heavy than the analytic types like Baldwin like. Too bad. Pete's philosophy of winning the turnover battle, have a strong run game that allows the team to control the pace of play and make sure the D is fresh, and make enough explosive plays to get TDs/FGs while preventing them on D... has been shown to be one way of winning. It's sometimes ugly but it gets the job done.

What we get to watch now as fans, is the process of Pete/John creating another SB-competitive team. They are one more great draft away from doing it with the draft capital they have now. Thiis team is just so much fun to watch from that perspective!

Expand full comment

This is my favorite post you've written.

All kinds of things I want to comment about, but I mostly wanted to say that.

Expand full comment
Oct 22, 2022Liked by Seaside Joe

I think Dissly gets called a blocking tight end because he looks like a blocking tight end. There are people who look at stats, those who look at the tape, and those who just look at photos and make assumptions.

Expand full comment

Pete Carrol is by far the best HC the Hawks have ever had... period..end of story!

Most wins. Most Super Bowls. Most Pro Bowl players.

I think the hatred comes from his days at USC and the interception that lost the 2nd Super Bowl even though there's no guarantee that Beast Mode would have scored . In that case the anti Pete crowd would have complained that they should have passed because the Pat's D was looking for the run.

So far he was right about Geno and trading Russ. ( it's better to trade a player a year early than year late)

The haul the Hawks got for Wilson was amazing plus they didn't have to give Wilson 50 million per season ,a contract that would have put a huge dent in the payroll.

Walker and Woolen are future pro bowlers.

The haters are gonna hate. Who really cares.

Expand full comment
Oct 22, 2022Liked by Seaside Joe

I have never used nor scrolled through Twitter. I don't HATE Twitter I have just never gotten envolved. Also i just got my hip replaced yesterday. I am home now and this has stirred a lot to think about. There is one point I do agree with Ben Baldwin and that is DJ Reed. Pete worked his DB magic on Reed and turned him into an above average cornerback, on the right side. Reed wanted to comeback to Seattle, but they gave him such a low ball offer that he would not deal with them ever. I can't understand why Pete took this approach.

On the positive side of Pete Kenneth referenced some good points i say some, because you could go on for a long time. As I have said here many times, I have never wanted Pete fired. I played for 2 coaches in my life that I would do almost anything for them, to win. I believe Pete is a guy like that.

Finally and most importantly look at the position Seattle is in, in the NFC West. I think the Niners were thinking correctly about McCaffery, the price was to high. To them, they are all in this year as they now have almost no picks in upcoming drafts. With their quarterback situation it's very understandable. The Rams are in a similar position and won a Super Bowl last year, but don't have a chance at a good draft next March. John and Pete and my friend Clive saw that Russell Wilson had lost a lot of his mobility. That mobility is what made him so much fun to watch, and he was dangerous. Last November my great friend Clive tentatively brought up Russell's play, Clive was a bit worried it might put my nose out of joint. On the contrary I thought the same. Pete and John spent hours times 100 figuring the future and they sure look good now. We have a team that competes with a bunch of players that are easy to get behind. Next year we have a chance to have a draft like this year's and bring in McCaw in round two or three. We have enormous cap space. We will be a good team meaning for sure playoff team, and by 2024, ascending to a fighers chance at the big prize. I would play for positive Pete !!!

Expand full comment
Oct 22, 2022·edited Oct 23, 2022Liked by Seaside Joe

I know there will be a better place to make this survivor comment but I'm old, I'd forget.

Van Dyke needs to return to school next year. He grabbed his right, throwing shoulder after a sack and didn't return so he might get a medical retirement from QB Survivor.

DJ Uiagalelei's draft stock took a major hit after he was benched and his replacement brought Clemson back against Duke.

"Expect the unexpected"!

We may need an injury substitution and Bo Nix looks like he should be in the competition. 22/28, 5 tds, 0 ints, 51 rds rushing but most of all, he looks like the game's most impactful player against UCLA.

Expand full comment
founding
Oct 23, 2022Liked by Seaside Joe

10+-win seasons under Pete Carroll: 8

10+-win seasons under all other coaches combined: 4

Post-season appearances under Pete Carroll: 9

Post-season appearances under all other coaches combined: 10

Post-season wins under Pete Carroll: 10

Post-season wins under all other coaches combined: 5

Ben Baldwin once argued to fire Carroll because of his use of timeouts and fourth-down calls. (I kid you not.) His position was that there were plenty of coaches-in-waiting out there (i.e., the road to Jim Mora). My comment was that anyone who would say this had never been in or had to hire a leadership position. Mike Dugar was gentler and more persuasive: He pointed out that Pete is very good at the hard parts of coaching a team—such as building and maintaining a successful culture—and that this was more important than what are minor tactical matters.

I’m in no hurry to move on from Pete.

Expand full comment
Oct 22, 2022Liked by Seaside Joe

Ol' Ben's shot about the QB trade, etc. sure is aging poorly, to date....

Expand full comment
Oct 22, 2022Liked by Seaside Joe

With Russ out this week is anyone else hoping that Rypien throws for 350 yards and 3 TD's and Denver has a full blown QB controversy on their hands?

Expand full comment
Oct 22, 2022Liked by Seaside Joe

So damn reasonable

Expand full comment
Oct 23, 2022Liked by Seaside Joe

Kind of like the ‘ I hate Jerry DiPoto’ gang that can’t stand that the rebuild is actually working. Some of the ‘Pete is holding Russ back’ crew have to be dying inside 😆

Expand full comment
(Banned)Oct 23, 2022Liked by Seaside Joe

This is the season that's pulling back the veil on Pete Carroll's coaching strengths as a head coach. I've never been a Carroll hater. In recent years, I've been wondering if was running out of gas. I no longer think so.

I've been very bearish on this team. Thought they'd win 2 to 5 games in 2022. They've been way better than I expected. Still don't see them making the playoffs but they deserve a lot of credit. Our rookies. Gino. Our excellent receivers. And our coaches.

Expand full comment