65 Comments
User's avatar
Hawkman54's avatar

This game was lost by the coaching staff! Why -again why, between the hash's are receivers for the other team almost always open by 3 to 7 yards??? and then Why are our receivers almost never open like that??? We have talent in the secondary ( although they really need to learn how to tackle) It simply has to be coaching! (and scheme, which is coaching). Then on offense why are we not sending a crosser on every play that starts with a notion of going deep! Sometimes they do, but watching the all 22 it is simply not enough! This team has the talent to be way better than what they are playing at this point of the season! Again Coaching. I have been a huge PC backer, But as of late he either needs to take the reigns a bit more or changes truly need to be made!

Expand full comment
Thomas Stewart's avatar

Three questions: 1) does DK know he can catch the ball with his hands? Balls bouncing off his shoulder pads all the time is super frustrating. How about DK helps his QB a little more? 2) does Diggs know he can use his arms when he tackles? If there was a prop bet that he bounces off Debo on Thursday no one would take it because it would be -100,000. I don’t know how this goes on week after week. 3) Does Geno know he can throw the ball away without incurring a grounding penalty? Someone should probably tell him. Bonus question: does Riq know it’s AGAINST THE RULES TO HIT ANOTHER PLAYER IN THE HEAD? Someone should probably tell him.

Expand full comment
Dale's avatar

I agree with the catching with the hands thing. Not sure if its the same as what you meant, but, as an Australian and as I played many years of Australian football, it is marking (ie. catching the football) 101 that you mark (catch) the ball out in front. ie. not on your chest and in your hands. I get frustrated watching Hawks players, including DK regularly, trying to catch the ball on his chest. If you catch the ball in your hands, out in front of your body, it makes it very difficult for a defender to reach the ball if they are trying to spoil it from behind. Not sure what you’re taught over there in the US.

Expand full comment
Paul G's avatar

DK had five catches for 95 yards. If anyone wasn’t the problem yesterday, it was DK.

Expand full comment
Thomas Stewart's avatar

DK is good. DK could be great. He’s not. It’s one of the reasons this offense doesn’t maximize its potential.

Expand full comment
Bryant's avatar

There was some good and some bad in this game, but nothing horrible or great. The closest to horrible for me was the penalties, you can’t win very often with over 120 yards in penalties. I’ve seen more “hands to the face” calls this season than I remember in most of my previous 60 years of fandom combined. Clean that up!

Both the offense and defense had shining moments followed by breakdowns.

Lock didn’t grab the bull by the horns when he had a chance to begin “the legend of Lock”. But Geno did almost create a legend for himself by executing the last drive that set them up for a FG to win.

Meyers didn’t lose this game. The Hawks can’t rely on him to make multiple 50 plus yard FG each week, they have to figure out how to get more TDs. For my money, Meyers might actually be the team MVP right now.

Overall the game reminded me of last week’s win over Washington. The Hawks appeared to be in control all game, but couldn’t quite get the big play to create an insurmountable lead. One was a last second win and one a last second loss. They need to figure out how to put teams away!

They still control their own destiny, but losing twice to the Rams is likely to haunt them at the end of the season.

Expand full comment
Paul G's avatar

With 35 seconds left, Geno completes a 21-yd pass to Metcalf (great). As the team rushes to lineup--presumably to spike the ball--Geno realizes that his headset isn’t receiving anything from Shane Waldron. He doesn’t look to the sideline for guidance, not that a 10-yr veteran should have any doubt about what to do (spike the ball). Instead, with 21 seconds left he calls a handoff to Charbonnet that goes for two yards and takes 14 seconds.

I.e., rather than 2nd-and-10 with 21 seconds left, its 2nd-and-8 with 7 seconds to go. That’s 14 seconds in which Seattle could have run two pass plays and gotten closer than 55 yds.

In fairness, maybe Geno did the right thing. The way his season has gone, it’s not inconceivable that given two passes, he would have held the ball too long and taken a sack or thrown an INT. But still...

Anyway this is what is maddening about Smith. Too often an impressive play is followed by a disappearing act or an outright brain fart.

Expand full comment
Mike McD's avatar

It's fair to criticize the run. However, the run should have worked given the defense. A similar play call worked great the prior week. Had the outcome been the same as the prior week, would you or people in general still be criticizing the decision?

2nd & 4 at WSH 45

(0:31 - 2nd) (Shotgun) Z.Charbonnet up the middle to WAS 33 for 12 yards (P.Butler).

Overall, I would have probably preferred to spike the ball. But there is no guarantee you get more yards. You also increase the risk of a sack or worse. QB is already banged up. I don't think it was a horrendous decision.

"It was a run that we didn't block properly ... and it should have popped. Should've popped for 10 yards..." - Pete 710 radio

Expand full comment
Paul G's avatar

According to KJ Wright, Football 101 is to spike the ball.

Expand full comment
Mike McD's avatar

If we are considering DK batman ... I think that Tyler would be Robin. He has had many big plays during crunch time.

I just finished rewatching the offense. One thing that came to mind is that many people say they want a new QB because Geno is not good enough. But by most accounts, Geno is a top 15 QB. For all the talk about weapons that we have, I am having a hard time seeing many who are a top 15 player at their respective position?

I think K9 is probably top 15 if not higher. Maybe/probably Damien Lewis? Maybe/probably Cross? Maybe Brown? Maybe you could say that our 2nd WR (Lockett) is a top 15 number 2 WR or that JSN is maybe a top 15 #3 WR?

I can't believe how many mistakes JSN makes week in and week out. How does he not turn his head on the Lock throw? Hard to reconcile simple but costly mistakes weekly with other good/great plays.

Is DK a top 15 #1 WR? I'm not sure about that. He can't make contested catches. And I like DK but he is no Chase, Jefferson, Hopkins, Adams, AJ Brown etc. Are we sure he is better than DJ Moore or Terry McLaurin?

Joe has talked about lack of blue chips on the defense in the offseason and rightfully so. But at what point do we take a look at the offense? I know people like to pile on Geno ... But what about the other guys? Why does the QB have to be a top 5 player, but no other position is held to that standard? Has any top 5 QB won a SB without other blue-chip player(s) (top 5 at their position) on their offense? I would highly doubt it.

Expand full comment
Grant's avatar

Woolen's illegal hands to the face on 3rd and 15 to keep the Rams' game-winning drive alive was the correct call and completely unnecessary and stupid. How are these guys still doing this after being flagged for it repeatedly all season long? Discipline!!! It's not just the coaching or just the players at fault either. Everyone on the team is accountable for those penalties.

Expand full comment
Dale's avatar

My thought when I saw that was that Woolen was sort of turning and pushed his hand out as a ‘push-off’ to accelerate and the guy who’s helmet he got just happened to also accelerate at that moment which caused his body to lean forward and lower. I think it was totally accidental and a case of unfortunate timing with how both players were naturally running. I don’t think it had anything to do with poor discipline.

Expand full comment
Hawkman54's avatar

Completely disagree , with all the calls of that nature the Hawks have had the coaching staff needs to teach/emphasis on keeping their hands down to below the shoulders! It is really truly simple to at least teach it!

Expand full comment
Dale's avatar

To be a bit clearer, I thought that when Woolen began to extend his arm, it was aimed at the other players chest, but he turned his head a fraction too soon and the other player dropped his chin to ‘take off’. I really don’t think he did too much wrong, it was just bad luck.

Expand full comment
Hawkman54's avatar

his hands were to high , and since they have been calling it very close ,and it seems on the Hawks a bit extra ,they ,the players and coaches should adjust after a several weeks of it!

Expand full comment
Dale's avatar

I agree with you overall, but I’ll agree to disagree on that one call.

Expand full comment
Grant's avatar

After hearing Pete talk about it, I agree that Woolen wasn't likely trying to hit the guy's face mask. It was an accident. They are being coached to jam the WRs at the line by striking their shoulder/chest and he just landed it too high. This goes back to Pete though. He's coaching these guys to be as aggressive as the rules allow for at all times and on every play. He knows the rules are constantly changing and that the hands to the face rule has been emphasized this season. Opposing coaches are going to tell their WRs to lower their chin coming off the line to try and get these over aggressive Seattle CBs in trouble. It is going to be called again and again until Pete/Hurtt make an adjustment.

Expand full comment
MOBILIZER's avatar

They're just not that good. It's not about a lack of talented players. The responsibility must lie at the top - it's about PC. The culture produces inconsistency and a lack of discipline. There's your hot take.

Expand full comment
KHammarling's avatar

I said 1-4 in the survey, and that 1 wasn't going to be the Rams. Look, everyone has a bogey team and/or coach. We have McVay and the Rams. I always knew this was going to be tricky game and one we'd need some lucky to win. Unfortunately Stafford was fine and our chance went wide right of the posts (no knock on Meyers, he's had a good game, missing from 54yds is allowed when he made other 50+yds in the same game).

We won't beat the 49ers on Thursday. We have a shot at the second match-up in a few weeks time. 1-4 still on for me, and needed. We need a shock to the system of a genuinely bad stretch to force the coaches into recognising where this team sits vs the big league hitters.

Anyway more about the actual game. Play calling regressed hard to my eyes, usual Waldron looks fancy does nothing. Geno was Geno, although overall he did have a good game. Actually a lot of the players had good games, and really I feel it was coaching that let the team down this week, plus penalties. Onwards to Thanksgiving!

Expand full comment
Dale's avatar

Didn’t get to see the game live. Just watched it now.

My take-aways:

1st half: I don’t think we did too bad in the first half. Geno was Geno - some ok plays, some bad passes and some luck. I thought Love was good in place of Adams. Charbs was good, Spoon was good. I thought the D was good. TV ads were as bad as ever. Tackling looked better. Rating: Good.

2nd half: Started ok. Not great, but ok. Spoon continued his excellent play. Offence started to stutter late in the 3/4. TV ads didn’t improve. D was still ok overall. Given the little he’s played, I thought Lock was ok. His missed long passes to JSN weren’t far off (in fact the 1st one was fine - JSN just turned too late to see the ball coming). Timing slightly out, but not by much. LA found a groove late in the last 1/4.

Rating: mediocre to poor (as the 1/2 went on).

After reading all the comments, I agree with most and think most are fair. Didn’t see what Parallax said, but I’ve always found him a bit bi-polar and can be harsh. I find him entertaining though.

Conclusion: I’ve never thought Geno is the answer. Nothing changed my opinion on that. He needs to go at the end of the season and we need to take the punt on a young recruit (Bo Nix?).

Bad call that allowed LA their 2nd TD turned the game. Nacau tripped himself up.

Dickson continues to be an absolute gun. He should be the highest paid kicker in the league with his consistency.

If we don’t get more creative with our offence, I can’t see us going far into the post season (if we make it). I’m starting to subscribe to the importance of Joe’s 8 minutes (though we are apparently the best when it comes to defending the last 2 minutes of the 1st 1/4).

Expand full comment
Grant's avatar

I'm surprised there aren't more comments about the DPI (called on Spoon, I think?) that gave the rams their 2nd half TD. That was the most game changing ref call of the day in my mind, and it was complete BS.

Expand full comment
Dale's avatar

Absolutely.

Expand full comment
Ronald Bone's avatar

I watched in wonder at the first Seahawks drive. Great mix of run and pass and we drove it right down the field and scored. After that, what the heck??? Its like Waldron is great at a weeks worth of script work but has no clue what to do during a game. I saw no play action after the first couple of drives even though it worked great at first. What gives??? Then, the last drive Geno actually started being aggressive with his throws, zipping the ball into space where the receivers were open. Why not the rest of the game for crying out loud??? Why is this offense so inept drive after drive??? (I wonder what Geno would be like playing for the 49ers? Would he shine like Brock Purdy or be just the same as he is for the Seahawks?)

Expand full comment
JohnnyLondon's avatar

I am with you. So much of Waldron’s cutesy formations are just glitzy window dressing for what are vanilla plays. Some of it was comically bad, in that he’s just running them irrespective of game situation, simply because they are in his playbook.

I know the alternative explanation - or a complimentary one - is lack of execution. But it’s hard to see how some of this stuff has worked on the practice field, given the failure rates on gameday.

Seems that Pete must have sanctioned the change in practice offensive philosophy, judging by the repeating run/pass splits too. That’s baffling.

Expand full comment
Mike McD's avatar

I find myself still thinking about the 8 most important minutes of football article this week by Joe since the end of this game.

Geez... did the Hawks mess that up today.

Expand full comment
Nicholas Donsky's avatar

Another brutal loss against a team we should have beaten. Sloppy , stupid penalty filled, undisciplined

play, no 1st downs in the 2nd half and a QB that isn't SB material.

To make matter worse, we have the worst OC in the NFL. On a 2nd and 20 he calls a two yard swing pass to a back , giving us very easy to convert 3rd and 18. Really?

Next year we draft a young. mobile QB and we say a fond farewell to Geno and Waldron.

Since Jamal Adam's unfortunately can't stay healthy , he's gone too

Maybe we can get a late round choice for him.

Until then we are cursed with a one and done at best , mediocre wild. card team. !

Expand full comment
Joel's avatar

I only watched the 1st quarter so I'm the one who came out ahead today.

Expand full comment
Defjames's avatar

This was an implosion, pure and simple. This had nothing to do with the refs, Myers, or the D. Our offense sucks, the O line is garbage, and we make stupid penalties at the worst possible time over and over again. The rams didn’t beat us, we handed them the game.

Step one is cleaning up the penalties and self inflicted stuff we can control. Step 2 is... I don’t know... stop doing stupid shhh...

I want to be mad, but honestly, I had a feeling we would blow it, I don’t believe this team will find a way to win, they find ways to lose. I guess I am mad, but it’s diluted because we always do this shhh. The rams aren’t good and we lost. That’s a fact.

Expand full comment
Sea Hawk Run!'s avatar

The Seahawks lost the game, but man, it sure felt like the officials were tilting things. There were two plays where the Rams were clearly offsides at the snap, but those weren’t called. There are a lot of calls that are subjective, but not those.

I’m not blaming the refs for the Seahawks losing this game. I am blaming the league for embracing Las Vegas and online betting, and missing obvious, objective calls. Please hide the corruption better so we can maintain the fantasy that the games are fair.

Expand full comment
Mike Lyman's avatar

The one that really irked me was the no call on the hit on Geno that injured him. Clearly a head shot for the second time by Donald. The Seahawks made numerous stupid mistakes but could have pulled this out like last week and several others.

Expand full comment
SR84's avatar

I’ve had some scotch and am trying to type on my cell phone so this won’t be pretty, just like the Seahawks. My thoughts:

The penalties have been bad all season and were inexcusable today. Cost us the game. I put that on Pete Caroll.

We abandon the run early and often. Zach looked good early. Pound the rock! No…instead we throw when we should stay with Zach and then run with him when we shouldn’t at the end. I put the terrible run/throw wisdom on leadership. Not sure if that is coaches or QB or both.

I guess my frustration is we should have won this game but penalties and poor play calling killed us. On Geno and Shane and Pete.

Kudos to the defense…too bad they wasted it on this game. Wow.

Redoux tomorrow.

Expand full comment
Rusty's avatar

Holy crap but those penalties just cost a game. The team CAN’T keep shooting themselves in the foot and have any hope of winning. This is not an even close game without the penalties. This crap needs to stop.

Expand full comment