The Seattle Seahawks are off this weekend and they return next Sunday to face the San Francisco 49ers in a game that should have significant playoff implications for both teams. So I’ll continue to answer questions from the Super Joes subscribers.
If you haven’t yet, rank your top 50 Seahawks:
Rank Your Top 50 Seahawks Here
If you want to join Super Joes, either to get the Q&A newsletter or just to support the newsletter for a few extra bucks, you can do so here:
Rusty: Ok. I’m going with the super stat nerd question. And it’s really for all Joes. Do you have a “lucky” jersey, or shirt, heck, even underwear that you wear for Seahawks games?
I have a shirt I wore for the last 4 regular season games plus playoffs last year, and apparently it’s not lucky this season, going 0-3. My NEW lucky shirt is 6-1, and was a black t shirt with a Seahawks logo in gray. I bleached out the black and tie dyed it in blue and green. What do you have?
I support the idea of superstitions, but they’ve never really worked for me. I’ll point to the community for answers on this one.
For example, Grant already shared a good one:
“I had a lucky baby for a while. She was born on Thanksgiving day in 2014 when we beat the 49ers. The Seahawks didn’t lose another game until the stupid Super Bowl against the stupid Patriots. We kept the kid, however.”
Anyone else have a lucky shirt or a lucky offspring?
Samuel Garfield: I've been told the Vikings defense is "clearly" number 1. What's the case for Seahawks vs. Vikings?
One thing to establish immediately is that the Seahawks and Vikings have faced virtually the same quality of offenses this season — at least generally speaking because I can’t account for every injury and condition that may have negatively impacted a team on those particular days.
Vikings opponents’ offensive EPA/play: +0.02 (12th toughest)
Seahawks opponents’ offensive EPA/play: +0.01 (13th toughest)
That set a good baseline that maybe strength of schedule isn’t going to have a dramatic impact on the comparison, although strength of schedule ALWAYS matters.
Where the Seahawks obviously win:
SEA Run Defense: 1st YPC, 6th in EPA/play, 2nd in RYOE/att
MIN Run Defense 19th YPC, 4th in EPA/play, 15th in RYOE/att
The Vikings allowed 230 rushing yards against the Vikings, whereas Seattle’s worst game is 147 yards allowed against the Chargers. The Seahawks have consistently been an elite run defense, including 50 yards allowed against Kenneth Walker’s Chiefs. This isn’t just strength of opponent, Macdonald has been consistent across the season.
If there’s a better run defense than Seattle’s, it’s Tampa Bay’s. They haven’t allowed 100 total rushing yards since Week 1. Or maybe the 49ers, they rank first in EPA/play and RYOE (rushing yards over expectation) per carry.
Where the Vikings obviously win:
MIN Red Zone Defense: 1st (5 TD in 20 trips)
SEA Red Zone Defense: 28th (16 TD in 23 trips)
I will address this stat again later in the newsletter, but I can’t totally debunk that red zone defense is much worse than expectations.
Both the Vikings and the Seahawks have top-5 third down defenses, and top-3 pass defenses. The Vikings have two edge rushers who have at least 8 sacks (Andrew Van Ginkel, Dallas Turner) and the Seahawks may not have an edge rusher reach 8 sacks all season (Derick Hall has 4, DeMarcus Lawrence has 2). Minnesota is 1 of 1 in pressure and sack rate.
Their sack rate is 3% points higher than second-place Houston. But Seattle doesn’t suffer in these areas either and Macdonald is very different than Brian Flores in that he gets pressure without sending extra rushers, which is probably part of the reason why the Seahawks have a better run defense.
For teams like the Vikings I wonder, “So you won’t face a single team in the playoffs that can’t beat a blitz?”
Only 4 teams in NFL history have led the league in sacks and won the Super Bowl that year.
The last to do it was the Broncos in 2015. The last team before them was the Giants in 2007. And the team before that was the 1999 St. Louis Rams, but I don’t think Kirk Cousins is leading the greatest show on turf part II.
(This wasn’t your question but I would still rank the NFC North as the Lions 1, the Bears 2, and the Vikings and Packers being tied for 3. Aidan Hutchinson’s injury doesn’t change much for my math there.)
Are the Seahawks or Vikings the number one defense? There is no clear cut answer. It depends on the matchup and what’s being asked of the defense that day. Overall, I don’t hate betting on a team that’s already won playoff games and had one of the most dominant postseasons ever.
Get someone the gift of Seaside Joe for Christmas—even if it’s yourself!
Danno: My question for you comes from all the experts saying the quality of the competition explains the difference of play between Lock and Darnold…I get that, but how do you use that to adjust the play? I watch the film and there is no question Lock is the better QB on a consistent basis...Part of me wishes Sam is out one more game so Lock will play a top tier team and we can see if it is the quality of competition that explains the clear difference on film…In any event, I am a firm believer that playoff Sam is perhaps a top 5-8 QB. Let’s see him against the 49ers and I will gladly welcome him turning the corner and taking us deep into the playoffs again.
(Commented edited down for space.)
Seeing Sam Darnold against the Cardinals or Raiders, or Drew Lock against the Broncos or 49ers, certainly would have helped answer some questions. I guess we will find out next Sunday. There’s nothing more I can add to the Lock-Darnold competition thing at this time.
The Seahawks are holding steady with Darnold, so that is the quarterback that fans will have to root for to prove them right or prove them wrong.
Chuck Turtleman: I don't think we've seen a healthy snap from Sam since first quarter vs the Patriots. I understand that there aren't many NFL snaps played at 100% health from any player, but he has looked so off to me. As have Lucas and occasionally Zabel.
Mike Macdonald did tell Seattle Sports on Monday that he doesn’t think Darnold has been fully healthy for most, if not all of the season.
“I can’t wait for him to be fully healthy, probably for the first time — minimal times it’s happened this year.”
So the theory that Darnold has been playing at less than 100% is at least repeated by the head coach.
Defjames: What is the most ridiculous/annoying perception about the Seahawks that should be challenged and disproven in the court of Seaside Joe?
Well, I’ll leave Sam Darnold’s turnovers out of it because that’s been talked about enough recently (not that it isn’t worthy of criticism or defense) but I think people tend to overlook how thin the margin is between a “good game” vs. a “bad game”, and ignore the impact of good turnover luck and bad turnover luck.
From an individual standpoint, I think the perception that Jason Myers is having a bad season or is “cooked” could be ridiculous.
Last season Myers missed:
1 kick between 20-29 yards
1 kick between 30-39 yards
2 kicks between 40-49 yards
3 kicks of 50+ yards
This season Myers has missed:
0 kicks between 20-29 yards
1 kick between 30-39 yards
2 kicks between 40-49 yards
0 kicks of 50+ yards
Myers was perfect on 48 extra points last season, and he’s 21-of-23 this season, so that’s off. However, he did shank a 26-yard field goal against the 49ers in 2025.
The narrative that Myers is cooked feels unfair at this point in the season. What if Myers doesn’t miss another field goal or extra point this year? It’s not that hard to believe that he could be perfect for seven games. Myers was also attempting about one more field goal try per game in 2025, so I have some questions of whether the offense is doing a good enough job to set him up for redemption. (Especially since the red zone offense hasn’t improved.)
As far as narratives about the entire team that could be annoying, I think I made a point like that earlier this week when I gave context to every defensive touchdown allowed by the Seahawks in 2026—and how that information should change our perceptions of Seattle’s red zone defense.
The Seahawks are a “bad” red zone defense? Well, yeah, the percentage of red zone trips that end in a touchdown is not what Macdonald would call acceptable.
But I think that the context of a defense that ends up starting a drive in their own territory because of turnovers by the offense is important:
How much easier is it to drive 21 yards against Seattle than 65 yards?
The Moons and the 49ers both scored multiple touchdowns against the Seahawks on short fields. Who wouldn’t take a “bad” red zone defense over a bad defense between the 1 and the 21? Seattle’s “bad red zone defense” to me is like being thrown into a cage match after you’ve just finished 10 rounds of boxing.
They were already up against the ropes. I’m not worried yet about the Seahawks’ red zone defense.




