The Seattle Seahawks extended Devon Witherspoon to a four-year, $132 million contract during training camp, which stood as the biggest number for a cornerback until Christian Gonzalez signed a $135 million contract with the Patriots three weeks later. Gonzalez is getting roasted this week for sliding into another dimension like Jerry O’Connell in coverage against Amon-Ra St. Brown:
But concerns of the Patriots having buyer’s remorse go well beyond his latest quantum leap. Gonzalez allowed 10 catches on 11 targets for 187 yards and a touchdown against the Green Bay Packers last week, and then he allowed 84 yards and another 2 touchdowns against the Lions on Sunday.
That’s 12 catches for 271 yards and 3 touchdowns allowed over the past two games alone, including 190 yards allowed when Gonzalez has been in man coverage, according to Next Gen Stats. Gonzalez has now allowed 467 yards in 2026 — third-most in the NFL — despite also missing two games with a shoulder injury.
This is not the company you want to keep when you’re the highest-paid cornerback in football:
Gonzalez is having a worse season than Roger McCreary, a corner making the vet minimum who was traded to the Rams last year with a sixth-round pick so the Titans could get a fifth-round pick. That’s the NFL’s definition of a player who has practically no value. I don’t bring any of this up as a “neener, neener, neener” type of way. Whatever happens to and with the Patriots is their problem, not ours.
Gonzalez may also be having a slump and a year from now people say “Wow, y’all overreacted to a guy slipping on a field all the way in Germany”.
That’s all fine, but it is important to remember just how fickle the business of sports is and how quickly a player — perhaps especially a cornerback — can look different from one season to the next. The Seahawks took a risk by extending a cornerback who isn’t “traditional” in many of the ways we first think of when we think of number one cornerbacks:
He’s not especially tall
He’s not especially big
So he’s not the first guy Mike Macdonald calls to cover Mike Evans or Puka Nacua or Davante Adams
That’s not a criticism of Witherspoon, it’s just reality. We tend to think of “CB1” as a Richard Sherman type. Someone you pay to mitigate the value of a WR1. That’s not Devon Witherspoon. For example:
Gonzalez has spent 444 snaps at CB (257 in pass coverage)
Witherspoon has spent 346 snaps at CB (162 in pass coverage)
The difference is the 181 snaps that Witherspoon has spent in the slot (152 in pass coverage) and the 45 snaps that Witherspoon has been called a linebacker. Instead of a cornerback, you could called him a Weaponspoon:
The “weakness” that prevents Witherspoon from shadowing Evans when the 49ers are driving down Seattle’s throat like nobody else has this season, his size, is also what becomes his greatest strength when combined with the defensive mind of Mike Macdonald. Instead of seeing Witherspoon as a player who he had to mold into an outside corner because “that’s where the value is”, Macdonald has created a chameleon.
(I don’t understand the term “chess piece” I guess, because each piece in chess has one very specific move it can make and nothing else, except for one. So wouldn’t the only appropriate term for a player who gets moved around be “Queen”?)
Witherspoon’s versatility became weaponized in Week 10’s win over the Las Vegas Raiders when Macdonald dialed up those two blitzes that Fernando Mendoza couldn’t see coming, let alone handle. I watched an interesting (and certainly biased) breakdown of Mendoza’s first start by Derek and David Carr:
Once the Seahawks saw enough from Mendoza and Klint Kubiak for Macdonald to see where he could get pressure, it was over for the Raiders. Witherspoon blitzed three times, resulting in two sacks and one quick pressure. Then in 35 coverage snaps, Witherspoon allowed zero catches.
I do think that there is important context with allowing zero catches on Sunday, which is that the Raiders are garbage. Sorry if that offends the Raiders (am I sorry though? not really) but they are.
Today was actually the first time all season that I realized that as Seahawks fans lament the loss of Kubiak because Seattle can’t do things like run the ball, the Raiders rank 32nd in running the ball. Would Ashton Jeanty be as bad as he is in Vegas if on the Seahawks? Maybe. But he couldn’t look worse.
Mendoza wasn’t ready for the Seahawks’ “welcome to the NFL” moment (coincidentally Mendoza’s debut came against the Patriots, although Gonzalez missed that game) and all of Seattle’s defensive players benefited from a relatively easy matchup. However, that doesn’t take away from Witherspoon once again flashing as a WEAPON — whether he is in coverage or not.
He doesn’t need to be in coverage to be a valuable player, which is not something that most cornerbacks can say.
As I wrote on Tuesday, the Seahawks have only allowed one passing touchdown over the last five games. In that time, they have faced the Broncos, Chiefs, Bears, Cardinals, and Raiders. This is neither the hardest schedule, nor the easiest. That’s just 89 points allowed in five games (17.8 per game) and seven touchdowns, including one pass, a one-yarder from Caleb Williams to Luther Burden.
And everyone is doing their part in coverage in those 5 games:
Witherspoon: 12/22, 102 yards, 0 TD
Jobe: 14/22, 118 yards, 0 TD
Emmanwori: 14/23, 108 yards, 1 TD (Bears)
Pritchett: 2/5, 31 yards, 0 TD
Love: 8/11, 75 yards, 0 TD
Okada: 5/9, 61 yards, 0 TD
Thomas: 12/14, 98 yards, 0 TD (3 games)
Jones: 17/23, 141 yards, 0 TD
It is hard to force incompletions as a linebacker, especially in today’s NFL, so the most fans can hope for is limiting the damage and preventing first downs and touchdowns, which Ernest Jones and Drake Thomas are doing. Players like Witherspoon and Nick Emmanwori bring another element to their game, which is the unpredictably of where they’ll end up after the snap—you can’t say for sure based on where they’re lined up before the snap.
How is the contract looking?
Relatively good! Any time a team commits this much money to a player they take a risk. Witherspoon was already signed through 2026, plus he had a fifth-year option in 2027 that the Seahawks picked up before his extension. He is signed through 2031.
The cap hit becomes large in 2028, which the Seahawks may elect to bring down with a restructure if they need to do that. It would make his 2029-2031 cap hits even bigger though.
If the contract felt like an “overpay” in August because Witherspoon isn’t the traditional outside cornerback, it at least should seem more reasonable 10 games into the season — because he isn’t a traditional outside cornerback.
Those guys do tend to slip.











What's wrong with "neener, neener, neener"?
Spoon’s contract is looking good. What’s the chance of a Charbs contract or Nelson contract this bye week?