Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Shaymus McFamous's avatar

I think you make a good case against tanking in this article, Ken. It takes more than just a handful of stars to be successful in the NFL, even if one of them is a record-setter. Also needed is good coaching and ability to pay those players. Any team GM who wants to sell off parts to get Caleb Williams or any other single probable future star can go right ahead and try, IMO. They better have a ton of draft picks in a draft that has tons of great players (compared to guys currently in the league) available in it. They better be good enough at evaluating those guys so that they hit on a very high percentage of those picks. They better have great coaching in place, and plenty of cap space. Seems like the Seahawks approach of building a stable organization and being patient and as efficient as possible to build a team without going all gung-ho is much more likely to be successful than needing ALL of those other things to go right.

Expand full comment
AggieHawk's avatar

Thanks, Ken.

I think the three player bias evolved because that was about the maximum that a media talking head could count on the mass audience remembering. Or maybe that’s the typical number of Jersey numbers per team that the NFL shop keeps in back stock.

I remember during the Cowboys’ last dynasty every announcer and analyst talked about their holy trinity of Troy Aikman, Emmett Smith, and Michael Irvin. If that was all they had defenses would have shut them down. And that ignores that on the other side of the ball the Cowboys’ defense might have actually been stronger! That team’s strength probably was its incredible depth, as it happened during the last years before free agency really kicked in.

Go back a little further, the headline for the Seahawks in, say, 1985 would be Curt Warner, Steve Largent, and Kenny Easley. (Give or take a player, but really 3 is all the casual fan has mental space for)

So the top three test is one of the more inaccurate ones out there, even if it’s good shorthand to see who is the most popular with the masses.

Expand full comment
51 more comments...

No posts