Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Mike McD's avatar

About the Geno thing. I just don't get it. My question is how many guys do you think are better? I certainly understand Mahomes, Burrow, Allen. But after that I am just not too sure. Blaming everything on the QB also runs the risk of letting some real issues go unaddressed. Also, I do not think any QB Mahomes, Brady, Marino could win with the team that trotted out there today.

Overall, Geno is not a great QB but can play that way at times. Geno is not a bad QB but can play that way at times. So what does that make him? He is somewhere around 5-15 best QB in the league. Here are the numbers:

FACTS

Since 2022 Geno is 11th in EPA+CPOE composite

In 2023 he is 15th in QBR and 15th in QB rating.

When the Hawks won the SB in 2013 RW was the 6th best QB in the league by EPA+CPOE.

Does Geno need to be better? You bet. So if someone tells me its time for Drew Lock ... That means that you believe that a 10-15 best QB in the league can't win. And this includes guys like Brock Purdy who is clearly a bottom tier QB playing on a really good team (look at Jimmy G).

I am a big Lock fan and believe that he is plan A for the future which could come this offseason. But, we are football team in first place and a great shot at making the playoffs. If you put Lock in and he is actually bad ... You throw that opportunity away.

The great thing about Geno is you know that he is extremely accurate, very efficient in play action, and very efficient from a clean pocket. So the question in my mind is less about Geno and more about: can you run the ball? Can you keep the pocket clean? And receivers ... catch the damn ball when it is thrown to you especially on third down.

Peace and love to all opinions.

Go Hawks!

Expand full comment
Rozone's avatar

Postgame interview had Pete refusing to even discuss Geno. He may need to pay attention to what the former players have said about him protecting Russell to the detriment of team morale. Postgame Geno is full of "that was on me," and "I need to do better." But, before the game he has the nerve to call himself EXCELLENT and is numb to noticing Lockett dumbfounded and unable to respond to that self-assessment. We've never heard Lockett, who is EXCELLENT, put that label on himself and then go out and miss every catch.

I've worked for bosses who were low performers and they just don't generate the incentive to anyone to carry them to glory knowing they will get the raise and the glowing review when the team achieves success. Geno needs Pete to come down hard on him rather than protect his fragile ego at the risk of him getting worse.

Expand full comment
89 more comments...

No posts